Introductory Business Law / Unit 1 BLW 0013 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Naming the School Behind an Argument
The idea
To name the school behind an argument, look for its signal. First, does the speaker say a rule binds because the sovereign enacted and enforces it? That is positivism. Second, does the speaker judge a law against a higher moral standard, or defend disobeying an unjust law? That is natural law. Third, does the speaker urge following the past because precedent should govern? That is the historical school. Fourth, does the speaker say outcomes turn on judges' beliefs and social change? That is legal realism. Fifth, does the speaker say law serves the wealthy and powerful? That is critical legal studies; if the domination is of women and nature, it is ecofeminism.
In practice
Case problem: four speakers at a town meeting discuss a new zoning code. Marta says, "The council passed it, so it binds us, like it or not": positivism. Dev says, "A code that bulldozes a family's home without justice is no true law": natural law. Rosa says, "Wait to see which judge hears the challenge; her views will decide it": legal realism. Glen says, "The code was written for the developers who fund the council": critical legal studies. 4 speakers, 4 different schools.
Where people slip
Do not confuse legal realism with critical legal studies. Realism says judges' beliefs shape rulings; critical legal studies says the powerful shape the law itself. This rests on one source.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Introductory Business Law