Introductory Business Law / Unit 1 BLW 0016 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Civil versus Criminal Cases
The idea
Civil and criminal cases differ in four ways. First, the parties: in a civil case a plaintiff sues a defendant, who must answer or lose by default; in a criminal case the government prosecutes a defendant, who may remain silent. Second, the burden of proof: civil cases need a preponderance, the greater weight of credible evidence; criminal cases need proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Third, the purpose: civil law settles disputes and compensates; criminal law maintains order, punishes and deters. Fourth, the remedy: civil remedies are money damages, injunctions and specific performance; criminal penalties are fines, jail and forfeiture. One act can lead to both kinds of case.
In practice
Case problem: Theo runs a red light and wrecks Bianca's car. The state charges Theo with reckless driving: a criminal case, brought by the government, needing proof beyond a reasonable doubt, with a fine as the penalty. Bianca sues Theo for $8,000 in repairs: a civil case, brought by her, which she wins if the greater weight of the evidence shows he caused the damage. The two cases run separately: any fine goes to the state, and the $8,000 in damages goes to Bianca.
Where people slip
Do not mix up the burdens: preponderance of the evidence is the civil standard; beyond a reasonable doubt is the criminal one. And a government can bring a civil case too, such as one to collect a debt.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Introductory Business Law