Skip to main content
SWStudyWalks Search Sign in

Introductory Business Law / Unit 1   BLW 0019 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds

Sorting One Dispute Into Every Category

Captions available

The idea

Every legal rule can be sorted four ways, and sorting first tells you which rules apply. First, public or private: does the rule apply to everyone, or bind only the parties? Second, civil or criminal: does a private party sue for compensation, or does the government prosecute? Third, substantive or procedural: does the rule set a duty, or the steps for enforcing one? Fourth, federal or state: which government made it? Then match each part of the dispute to its category.

In practice

Case problem: Lark Bakery contracts with Brightway Ovens to buy a commercial oven, but Brightway delivers a broken one and refuses to replace it. Lark sues in a state court. The contract is private law; the suit is civil, seeking money for the loss; Brightway's duty to deliver a working oven is substantive; the court's rule that Brightway must answer the complaint within a set time is procedural; and the contract claim arises under state law. Lark must prove its case by a preponderance of the evidence. The 4 sortings give 4 answers: private, civil, substantive enforced through procedural rules, and state.

Where people slip

One dispute often touches both sides of a pair. A civil suit follows procedural rules while it enforces a substantive right; a common error is labeling the whole case by one rule. This rests on one source.

Your place on the trail

Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.

Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it  ·  Sources for Introductory Business Law