Skip to main content
SWStudyWalks Search Sign in

Introductory Business Law / Unit 1   BLW 0010 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds

One Decree, Two Schools

Captions available

The idea

To analyze a law by school, work in steps. First, ask the positivist question: did a recognized sovereign issue the rule and enforce it? If so, it is law, and its morality does not change that. Second, ask the natural-law question: does it conform to universal moral principles? If not, natural-law thinkers deny its legitimacy and hold that a citizen is morally justified in civil disobedience. Third, apply each answer to the person who disobeys. Natural law has shaped American thought: the ideas that some rights are unalienable and that government rests on the consent of the governed come from it.

In practice

Case problem: the ruler of the invented nation of Corvel decrees that members of one religion may not own shops, and police close their shops. Ilsa, a shopkeeper of that faith, reopens openly and accepts arrest. A positivist says the decree is valid law because the sovereign issued and enforces it, and Ilsa broke it. A natural-law thinker says the decree violates a universal moral order, so it lacks legitimacy, and Ilsa's open disobedience is a moral act. Both agree on what the decree says; they disagree on whether it deserves obedience.

Where people slip

Do not say a positivist approves of a bad law. Positivism describes what the law is; natural law asks what it should be. This rests on one source.

Your place on the trail

Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.

Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it  ·  Sources for Introductory Business Law