English 10 / Unit 1 EN10 0007 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Answering with Evidence and Commentary
The idea
Commentary is your own explanation of what a piece of evidence shows and why it answers the question. First, mark the key words of the question. Second, find the part of the text to read closely. Third, choose the two or three details that fit best. Fourth, write your answer in one sentence. Fifth, add the evidence, and after it add commentary that links it to your answer.
In practice
Worked example: Lena's question is why the banker thinks execution is kinder than prison. Step one: she marks the words kinder and prison. Step two: she rereads the banker's first speech at the party. Step three: she picks his claim about speed. Step four: she writes that the banker thinks a quick death is less cruel than a slow one. Step five: she quotes him from the 1915 translation by Koteliansky and Murry: "Execution kills instantly, life-imprisonment kills by degrees." Then she adds her commentary. The banker sees prison as a slower way of killing, so he calls it the crueler punishment.
Where people slip
Evidence without commentary leaves the reader to do your thinking. Commentary without evidence is only opinion. Give both every time.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for English 10