Skip to main content
SWStudyWalks Search Sign in

English 10 / Unit 1   EN10 0019 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds

Preparing Evidence for a Discussion

Captions available

The idea

First, reread the text and the discussion question. Second, write your claim in one sentence. Third, mark two pieces of evidence that support it. Fourth, write one question you want others to answer. Fifth, plan how you will respond when someone disagrees, starting from the text.

In practice

Worked example: Felix prepares to discuss whether the bet makes sense to either man. Step one: he rereads part one and the question. Step two: his claim is that the banker himself no longer believes in the bet. Step three: he marks the question the banker asks himself, "Why did I make this bet?", and the banker's own answer, "the caprice of a well-fed man," which means a rich man's whim. Step four: he writes a question for the group, which is what the lawyer hoped to gain besides money. Step five: if someone says the lawyer was greedy, Felix will answer from the text. The banker is the one who calls it "pure greed of gold," so the charge comes from him, not from the narrator.

Where people slip

Evidence prepared ahead keeps a discussion on the text. A discussion with no evidence is a chat about opinions.

Your place on the trail

Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.

Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it  ·  Sources for English 10