Skip to main content
SWStudyWalks Search Sign in

Introductory Business Law / Unit 1   BLW 0006 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds

Judging a Legal System by Its Functions

Captions available

The idea

To judge how well a legal system works, test it against the six functions in steps. First, list them: keep the peace, maintain the status quo, preserve individual rights, protect minorities, promote social justice and provide for orderly change. Second, for each one, ask whether the system's laws and their enforcement deliver it in practice, not only on paper. Third, count the functions served and the functions failed. A system can score well on order and badly on rights: an authoritarian government often keeps the peace and the status quo while oppressing minorities and political opponents.

In practice

Case problem: the invented nation of Valoria is ruled by a general. The streets are calm and the old ruling families keep their land, so peace and the status quo are served. Critics of the general are jailed without trial, one ethnic group may not own businesses, nothing is done for the poor, and the constitution changes only by the general's decree. Rights, minorities, social justice and orderly change all fail. Valoria serves 2 of the 6 functions, and 6 − 2 = 4 fail, so its order hides a weak legal system.

Where people slip

A calm country is not proof of a strong legal system. A common error is counting peace alone; ask which functions a system serves and which it fails.

Your place on the trail

Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.

Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it  ·  Sources for Introductory Business Law