StudyWalks finals are multiple choice, so the writing in a language arts course is the parent’s to assign and grade. This pack gives you 52 prompts tied to the units of six courses, an analytic rubric for essays, a narrative rubric for personal narratives and a research paper rubric, annotated model answers for the English 9 and English 10 prompts, a guide to the writing process, a grading sheet and a record of the year’s essays. StudyWalks never scores an essay; the parent does.
Nine steps, each tied to the College Composition units that teach it. Students in the literature courses can use the same steps; the unit references point to where each skill is taught.
Score each criterion from 4 to 1, then add the four scores (16 points in all). Use the same rubric for every essay prompt; the prompt sets the task, the rubric sets the standard. Personal narratives (English 9 prompt 1) use the narrative rubric that follows, and the English 10 research paper (prompt 8) uses the research paper rubric.
The scale is a starting point. You set the grade, and you may weight criteria differently for a particular prompt (for example, double the evidence score on a research essay).
Prompts: English 9
English 9 has eight prompts, one for each writing skill the course builds: a personal narrative, essays about a story, a poem, a play, an epic and a novel, an argument on a local question and a short research essay. Each is taught step by step in the last lesson of the unit it follows. Grade prompt 1 with the narrative rubric and prompts 2 to 8 with the pack's rubric. Two optional tasks, a talk and a timed essay, follow the eight. Model answers for every prompt come after the prompts. Course page: English 9.
1. A Turning Point
Personal narrativeLength: 600–900 · After unit 6 (Writing Narratives)
Write a true story about one moment that changed you: a choice, a discovery, a loss or a first time. Choose one moment, not a whole season. Open with a hook, order the events with time transitions, and slow down at the key moment so it gets the most space. Use dialogue and sensory detail to show what happened, and close by reflecting on what the moment meant to you. Helen Keller's account of the well-house, studied in unit 6, is a model of a turning point told plainly.
Grade with the narrative rubric.
Model answers for this prompt
2. Suspense or Irony in a Story
Literary analysis: storyLength: 600–900 · After units 3 (The Short Story I: Plot, Conflict, Setting and Point of View); 4 (The Short Story II: Character, Theme, Irony, Mood and Suspense); 10 (Writing About Literature: Claims, Evidence, Quotation and Analysis)
Choose one public-domain story from this course, such as "The Monkey's Paw", "The Gift of the Magi", "The Story of an Hour", "The Open Window" or "The Cask of Amontillado". Explain how the writer builds suspense or irony. State a claim a careful reader could argue with, and support it with at least three short quotations from different parts of the story. Introduce and cite each quotation, explain what it shows, and write in the present tense. Analyze how and why; do not retell the plot.
Model answers for this prompt
3. A Poem's Imagery and Form
Poetry explicationLength: 500–800 · After units 7 (Poetry I: Speaker, Imagery and Figurative Language); 8 (Poetry II: Sound, Rhythm, Meter and Form); 10 (Writing About Literature: Claims, Evidence, Quotation and Analysis)
Choose one public-domain poem from units 7 and 8. Explain how its imagery and its form (its lines and stanzas, rhyme, meter, or the turn of a sonnet) work together to create its meaning. Your thesis names the poem's meaning and the two or three devices that build it. Quote the lines you discuss, mark each line break with a slash, and explain every quotation.
Model answers for this prompt
4. Who Is Responsible
Argument about literatureLength: 800–1,000 · After units 13 (Romeo and Juliet I: Acts 1 and 2); 14 (Romeo and Juliet II: Acts 3 to 5, Tragedy and Its Sources)
Who or what is most responsible for the deaths in Romeo and Juliet: the feud, one character, the lovers' haste or chance? Argue for one main cause rather than blaming everyone a little. Support your claim with evidence from at least three acts, and name the speaker and the act and scene for every line you quote. Answer the strongest counterclaim fairly.
Model answers for this prompt
5. Hospitality or Heroism
Informative and analyticalLength: 800–1,000 · After units 16 (The Epic and the Hero: Homer, the Oral Tradition and Epic Conventions); 17 (The Odyssey I: Books 1 to 12); 18 (The Odyssey II: Books 13 to 24, Homecoming and Its Echoes); 23 (Writing to Inform and Explain)
What does the Odyssey show about hospitality (xenia, the guest-friendship of Homer's world) or about heroism? Choose one. Build the essay on three episodes from different parts of the poem, quote briefly from each in the Butcher and Lang translation, and explain each quotation in your own words. Organize by points, not by the order of the plot. Where the poem troubles you, give both readings fairly.
Model answers for this prompt
6. The Frame and the Reveal
Literary analysis: novelLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 19 (The Novel: Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde)
How do the frame (Utterson's investigation) and the delayed reveal (the two documents at the end) shape Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde? Choose three parts of the book, quote briefly from each, and explain how each part's place in the structure affects the reader. Write about how the book is built, not only about what happens in it.
Model answers for this prompt
7. A Local Question
Argument on an issueLength: 800–1,000 · After units 21 (Argument and Rhetoric: Claims, Evidence, Appeals and Fallacies); 24 (Writing Arguments)
Take a position on a real question that your town, neighborhood, church or club is deciding. State a precise claim a fair reader could dispute, and support it with three reasons, each with evidence and an explanation of how the evidence proves it. State the strongest opposing view as its supporters would, then answer it. Check the draft for the fallacies of unit 21, and end with a call to action.
Model answers for this prompt
8. A Short Research Essay
Short research essayLength: 1,000–1,500, plus a works cited list (MLA) · After unit 25 (Short Research: Questions, Sources, Quotation, Citation and Plagiarism)
Answer a research question that grows out of any unit of this course. Use at least four sources, including at least one primary text. Check each secondary source's author, publisher, date and evidence, and drop any that fail. Keep quotation, paraphrase and summary apart in your notes. Cite every borrowed word and idea in MLA style, in the sentence and in a works cited list. Let your own thesis lead, and use the sources as support.
Model answers for this prompt
Optional: A Talk
PresentationLength: 4 to 6 minutes · After unit 26 (Speaking, Listening and Media)
Deliver your essay for prompt 7 or 8 aloud to your family. Pick one main message and your strongest evidence, speak from short notes rather than a script, plan one or two simple visuals, rehearse with a timer, and answer the audience's questions at the end. The parent uses the speaking checklist below; the talk is not scored on the 16-point rubric.
Use the speaking checklist or the debate checklist.
Optional: A Timed Essay
Timed analysisLength: 45 minutes · After unit 27 (Capstone: Reading and Writing Across the Genres)
The parent chooses a short public-domain poem or prose passage the course did not quote, and a task such as "Explain how the writer uses imagery to create mood." In 45 minutes: read the prompt twice and mark its task words, mark three pieces of evidence, write a one-sentence thesis, plan for five minutes, draft, and save five minutes to proofread. Grade it with the pack's rubric, allowing for a first draft.
Speaking checklist (the optional talk)
Tick each line the talk meets. It is a checklist for feedback, not a score.
- States one main message near the start, and the audience can repeat it afterward.
- Supports the message with the strongest evidence from the essay, with sources named aloud.
- Uses signpost words (first, next, finally) so listeners can follow the order.
- Speaks from notes, not a script, at a steady rate and a volume the whole room can hear.
- Looks at the audience for most of the talk.
- Uses one or two visuals that help, not distract.
- Finishes within 4 to 6 minutes.
- Answers questions with evidence, and says so plainly when an answer is not known.
Prompts: English 10
English 10 has eight prompts, one for each major writing task of the year: an argument about a Greek tragedy, a comparison of two world stories, an essay on poems in translation, a rhetorical analysis, an essay on a novel, an essay on a play or on war poems, an extended argument with sources, and a research paper. Each is taught step by step in the last lesson of the unit it follows. Grade prompts 1 to 7 with the pack's rubric and prompt 8 with the research paper rubric; the research paper also has a checkpoint sheet for the parent and a four-week schedule. Three optional tasks follow the eight: a satire, a speech or debate, and a timed essay. Model answers for every prompt come after the prompts: prompts 2, 4 and 7 have models at four score levels, and prompts 1, 3, 5, 6 and 8 have a top-level model and a note on what lowers the score. The parent grades every essay. Course page: English 10.
1. Whose Law Should Rule?
Argument about literatureLength: 800–1,000 · After units 4 (Greek Tragedy I: The Athenian Theater and Antigone); 5 (Greek Tragedy II: Law, Conscience and the Tragic Hero)
In Sophocles' Antigone, Creon forbids anyone to bury Polyneices, and Antigone buries him anyway. Whose law should rule in Thebes: Creon's edict, or the unwritten laws Antigone obeys? Take a side and state it as a claim a careful reader could argue with. Use Francis Storr's translation, name him at your first quotation, and support your claim with short quotations from at least three different moments of the play, naming the speaker of each. State the strongest counterclaim as its supporters would, then answer it fairly. Argue from the play itself; do not retell it.
Model answers for this prompt
2. Two Stories, One Theme
Comparative literary analysisLength: 900–1,200 · After units 7 (World Short Fiction I: Nineteenth-Century Realism); 8 (World Short Fiction II: Modern Stories Across Cultures); 9 (Writing Comparative Literary Analysis)
Choose two world stories from units 7 and 8, such as "The Necklace" and "The Bet", and compare them on one theme they share. Name your basis of comparison, then make a thesis about how the stories are alike and how they differ. Organize point by point or in two blocks, quote briefly from both stories for every point, and explain each quotation in your own words. Name each translator at the first quotation, keep to the literary present, and end with a works cited list that names both stories, their translators and the books you read them in.
Model answers for this prompt
3. Two Translators, One Poem
Poetry and translationLength: 600–900 · After unit 10 (World Poetry in Translation)
Choose one poem that two public-domain translators have put into English, such as Li Bai's "River-Merchant's Wife" in Ezra Pound's Cathay (1915) and in Arthur Waley's version (1919), or the pair your parent gives you from unit 10. Read both aloud twice and set the matching lines side by side. Group the differences under two or three points, such as voice, form and ending, and argue what each translator's choices emphasize. Quote both versions for every point, credit every word choice to the translator, and argue only from the English poems, never from guesses about the original language.
Model answers for this prompt
4. How a Speech Persuades
Rhetorical analysisLength: 800–1,100 · After units 11 (Julius Caesar I: Shakespeare's Rome, Acts 1 and 2); 12 (Julius Caesar II: Acts 3 to 5, the Funeral Speeches and Plutarch); 13 (Rhetoric I: The Rhetorical Situation, Appeals and Devices); 14 (Rhetoric II: Speeches and Documents Across Time)
Choose Mark Antony's funeral speech in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar (act 3, scene 2) or one speech from unit 14, such as Pericles, Elizabeth I, Patrick Henry, Washington, Sojourner Truth, Chief Joseph or Susan B. Anthony. Explain how the speech persuades its audience. Begin with the situation: who speaks, to whom, when and why. Then analyze the appeals and devices, quoting briefly and explaining how each one works on this audience, not just what it is called. If the speech reaches us through a translator or a reporter, name that person and treat the text as that person's version.
Model answers for this prompt
5. Creator or Creature?
Literary analysis: novelLength: 1,000–1,200 · After units 17 (The Novel I: Frankenstein, the Letters and Volume I); 18 (The Novel II: Frankenstein, Volumes II and III, and Its Sources)
Write a literary analysis of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (the 1818 text). Choose one question. Who is more responsible for the deaths in the novel, the creator or the creature? Or, how do the nested narrators (Walton, Victor and the creature) shape the way we judge the creature? Build your claim on at least three moments from different parts of the book. Quote briefly, name the narrator of every quotation, and cite volume and chapter. Give interpretations as readings, not as facts, and answer the strongest counterclaim.
Model answers for this prompt
6. Nora's Choice, or Two War Poets
Analytical essayLength: 800–1,000 · After units 19 (Poetry of War and the Modern World); 20 (Modern Drama: A Doll's House)
Choose one. (a) In Ibsen's A Doll's House, why does Nora leave? Argue that her final choice grows from the whole play, using R. Farquharson Sharp's translation and, if you compare wording, William Archer's, naming the translator whenever you quote. (b) How do two war poets from unit 19, such as Rupert Brooke and Wilfred Owen, differ in tone toward the same war? Whichever you choose, state a claim, support it with at least three explained quotations, and treat other views of the ending, or of the war, as readings to be answered fairly.
Model answers for this prompt
7. A Question Worth Arguing
Extended argument with sourcesLength: 1,200–1,500 · After units 21 (Evaluating Arguments: Reasoning, Evidence and Fallacies in Depth); 22 (Writing Arguments II: The Extended Argument and Synthesis)
Take a position on a real ethical question that your town, school, church or club faces. State a precise claim a fair reader could dispute. Use at least three sources and make them talk to each other: at least one public-domain text from this course (for example Thoreau, Washington's Farewell Address or Woolf's A Room of One's Own) and others you have checked for authority and accuracy. Every source must be real; do not invent a study or a quotation. Map each reason to evidence before you draft, answer the strongest counterclaim, check your logic for fallacies, and end with a works cited list.
Model answers for this prompt
8. The Research Paper
Research paperLength: 2,000–2,500, plus a works cited list (MLA) · After units 23 (Research I: Inquiry, Searching and Evaluating Sources); 24 (Research II: Synthesis, Citation and the Research Paper)
Write a research paper on a question that grows out of any unit of this course. Use at least six sources, including at least two primary sources. Test every source for authority, accuracy, currency and purpose, and drop any that fail. Keep quotation, paraphrase and your own comments apart in your notes, and cite every borrowed word and idea in MLA style, in the sentence and in the works cited list. Let your thesis, not your sources, organize the paper. Work through the checkpoints on the four-week schedule: proposal, annotated bibliography, outline, draft, revision, and the final paper. The parent signs each checkpoint and grades the paper with the research paper rubric.
Grade with the research paper rubric; sign off each stage on the checkpoint sheet.
Model answers for this prompt
Optional: A Satire in Swift's Manner
Original satireLength: 500–800, plus a 150-word explanation · After unit 15 (Satire and Irony as Argument)
Write a short satire in the manner of Swift's A Modest Proposal about a harmless modern habit, such as always checking a phone or over-planning a free afternoon. Speak through a calm persona who proposes a reasonable-sounding remedy, and let the irony do the work. The target must be the habit or the policy, never a person or a group of people, and never anyone who is weak or poor, as Swift's target was the cruelty of the policies and never the children. Add a 150-word explanation naming your target and your techniques. The parent grades with the narrative rubric, scoring technique as satirical technique.
Grade with the narrative rubric.
Optional: A Speech or a Debate
Speech or debateLength: 5 to 7 minutes, or one debate round · After unit 25 (Speech and Debate)
Choose one. (a) Deliver your essay for prompt 7 or 8 as a persuasive speech of five to seven minutes, with one main message, your strongest evidence, notes instead of a script and a timed rehearsal. (b) Debate one round on a resolution your parent sets, with a parent or sibling as your opponent: build a case, ask and answer questions in cross-examination, flow your opponent's speech and refute it fairly. The parent uses the speaking checklist for a speech and the debate checklist for a round. The task is not scored on the 16-point rubric.
Use the speaking checklist or the debate checklist.
Optional: A Timed Essay
Timed analysisLength: 45 minutes · After unit 27 (Capstone: Reading and Writing Across World Literature)
The parent chooses a short public-domain passage the course did not quote, in prose or verse, and a task such as "Explain how the writer uses a persona to make an argument." In 45 minutes: read the passage twice, plan for ten minutes with a claim and three pieces of evidence, write for about twenty-five, and keep five to check quotations and citations. Grade it with the pack's rubric, allowing for a first draft.
Debate checklist (the optional debate round)
Tick each line the round meets. It is a checklist for feedback, not a score. For a speech, use the speaking checklist with the English 9 prompts.
- States the resolution fairly and presents one clear case with two or three issues in the first speech.
- Supports each issue with evidence the other side can check, and names the source aloud.
- Restates the opponent's best point fairly before answering it, then answers it, supports the answer and says why it matters.
- Asks short, pointed questions in cross-examination, and answers the opponent's questions directly and briefly.
- Flows the opponent's speech, answers the points that matter and notices any point left unanswered.
- Keeps to the time limits for every speech and for cross-examination.
- Attacks the argument, never the person, waits for a turn to speak and thanks the opponent at the end.
- After the round, names the weakest answer and one change for next time.
Prompts: College Composition
Composition prompts practice the course's skills in order: the rhetorical situation, then sentences and revision, then argument, research and analysis. Use the student's own topics where a prompt allows it. Course page: College Composition.
1. The rhetorical situation
Short analysisLength: 500–700 · After unit 1 (Writing for a Purpose)
Choose a piece of writing you met this week outside your studies: a letter, an advertisement, a news story, a set of instructions or a post. Identify its purpose, audience, context and genre. Then explain two choices the writer made (words, length, order, tone or format) because of that situation, and one choice you would change for a different audience.
2. Revision, before and after
Revision with memoLength: Revised essay plus a 300-word memo · After units 12 (Revision as a Process); 14 (Paragraphs); 20 (Revising a Whole Passage)
Take an essay you wrote earlier in the course. Revise it from large to small: test the thesis, reorder or cut paragraphs, develop the thinnest paragraph with evidence, then edit sentences. Hand in both versions and a memo that names your three biggest changes and why each one helps a reader.
3. An argument about your community
ArgumentLength: 800–1,000 · After units 13 (Thesis Statements); 15 (Organization and Reasoning Patterns); 17 (Evidence and Support); 30 (Reasoning and Fallacies)
Take a position on a question your town, church, club or family is actually deciding. State an arguable thesis, support it with at least three reasons and specific evidence, and answer the strongest objection fairly. Before you hand it in, check your reasoning against the fallacies in unit 30 and remove any you find.
4. Rhetorical analysis of a speech
Rhetorical analysisLength: 900–1,200 · After units 28 (Rhetorical Appeals); 29 (Language, Tone and Structure)
Choose a speech or essay written to persuade a particular audience (the parent may approve the choice). Analyze how the writer appeals to that audience through credibility, emotion and reasoning, and how tone, figurative language and structure support those appeals. Your thesis should say what the writer does and why it works or does not, not whether you agree.
5. Testing an argument
Argument analysisLength: 800–1,000 · After units 30 (Reasoning and Fallacies); 31 (Analyzing Arguments and Evidence)
Choose an editorial or opinion column. Identify its main claim, its evidence and the assumptions the argument needs. Evaluate the reasoning: where is it strongest, where does it rely on a fallacy or on evidence that fails the tests of unit 17? End with what the writer would need to add to persuade a skeptical reader.
6. Synthesis: sources in conversation
SynthesisLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 23 (Integrating Sources)
Read three sources that take different positions on one question. Write an essay that makes your own claim about the question and puts the sources in conversation: where they agree, where they disagree and why. Use quotation, paraphrase and summary, each at least once, with signal phrases, and keep your own voice in control of every paragraph.
7. Research essay
ResearchLength: 1,500–2,000 with works cited · After units 21 (Research and Sources); 22 (Evaluating Sources); 23 (Integrating Sources); 24 (Plagiarism and Documentation); 25 (MLA Style); 26 (APA Style)
Write a research essay on a question you choose and the parent approves. Use at least five sources, including at least two print or scholarly sources, and evaluate each against the five criteria of unit 22. Hand in a research log, an annotated bibliography, the drafts and the final essay, documented in MLA or APA style.
8. Timed essay
Timed argumentLength: 40 minutes · After units 13 (Thesis Statements); 14 (Paragraphs); 17 (Evidence and Support)
With no notes, in 40 minutes, respond to this prompt: 'Some people say that the most important skill a person can learn in school is how to learn on one's own. Do you agree or disagree?' Plan for 5 minutes, write for 30 and proofread for 5. The parent may substitute any arguable question and repeat the exercise during the year.
Prompts: American Literature
American Literature prompts follow the course's periods. Each names works the course teaches; the student reads the work itself, not only the lessons. Works published before 1931 are in the U.S. public domain and free in online collections; a work marked (in copyright) needs a library copy or an authorized edition. This pack quotes none of the copyrighted works. Course page: American Literature.
1. Douglass and the authenticating letters
Literary analysisLength: 900–1,200 · After unit 9 (Slavery, Reform, and the Woman Question)
Douglass's Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845) appeared with prefaces by white abolitionists testifying that he wrote it. Why did the book need them? Analyze how Douglass's own voice and the scenes he chooses establish his authority beyond what the prefaces could give him.
2. The individual and society in Concord
ComparisonLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 7 (Transcendentalism: Emerson, Thoreau, Fuller)
Compare Emerson's "Self-Reliance" with Thoreau's "Resistance to Civil Government" ("Civil Disobedience"). Each argues for the individual conscience against social pressure. How do they differ in what that conscience should do? Use at least three quotations from each.
3. Poe's method, tested
Literary analysisLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 8 (The Dark Romantics: Poe, Hawthorne, Melville)
In "The Philosophy of Composition" Poe claims he wrote "The Raven" by working backward from the effect he wanted. Test the claim against the poem: which of its features (refrain, meter, setting, the bird's one word) serve a single effect, and does anything in the poem resist his account?
4. Two poets, one problem
ComparisonLength: 900–1,200 · After unit 10 (Whitman and Dickinson)
Set the opening of Whitman's "Song of Myself" beside Dickinson's "Because I could not stop for Death". Compare form (line, meter, stanza), the speaker and what each poem does with the self. What does each poet gain from the form the other avoided?
5. The ending of Huckleberry Finn
ArgumentLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 11 (Realism and Regionalism)
In the last chapters of Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Tom Sawyer turns Jim's escape into a game long after he knows Jim is legally free. Readers have argued ever since about whether the ending ruins the book or exposes something true. Take a side, use evidence from the novel's narration, and answer the other side's best point.
6. What the poem asks of the reader
ComparisonLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 14 (Modernist Poetry)
Compare Frost's "Mending Wall" with Williams's "The Red Wheelbarrow". What does each poem leave unsaid, and what work does it ask the reader to do? Connect your reading to the course's account of how the modernists broke with earlier poetry.
7. Nick Carraway as narrator
Literary analysisLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 15 (Modernist Fiction and Drama)
Nick Carraway claims to be one of the few honest people he has known, and everything in The Great Gatsby reaches us through him, including scenes he did not see. Is he a reliable narrator? Argue your answer from at least three passages, and explain how your answer changes the way the novel judges Gatsby.
8. King's letter as argument
Rhetorical analysisLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 17 (Postwar Poetry and Drama)
Analyze Martin Luther King Jr.'s "Letter from Birmingham Jail" (1963; in copyright: read it in a library anthology or an authorized edition) as an argument addressed to a specific audience, the eight clergymen whose public statement it answers. How does King establish his authority, answer the charge that the demonstrations were badly timed, and use reasoning and emotion together? This prompt pairs with Composition units 28–31.
9. A movement in two works
ResearchLength: 1,500–2,000 with works cited · After units 4 (Puritan New England); 7 (Transcendentalism: Emerson, Thoreau, Fuller); 11 (Realism and Regionalism); 13 (The Harlem Renaissance); 14 (Modernist Poetry)
Choose one movement the course teaches (Puritan writing, Transcendentalism, Realism, the Harlem Renaissance or Modernism). Argue what its central claim was, and show how two works by different writers express or complicate it. Use at least three secondary sources, documented in MLA style.
Prompts: English Literature
English Literature prompts run from Beowulf to postcolonial writing, following the course's periods. Most works are free in public-domain collections; use a modern-English translation for Beowulf and an edition with glosses for Chaucer. A work marked (in copyright) needs a library copy or an authorized edition; this pack quotes none of the copyrighted works. Course page: English Literature.
1. The heroic code in Beowulf
Literary analysisLength: 900–1,200 · After unit 3 (Old English Literature)
Beowulf praises the warrior who seeks glory. Does the poem also count its costs? Analyze two or three episodes (a boast, a fight, the ending) and argue what the poem finally values.
2. Chaucer's pilgrims
Literary analysisLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 4 (Geoffrey Chaucer)
Choose two portraits from the General Prologue of The Canterbury Tales. Show how the narrator's apparently innocent praise lets the reader see what he does not say. What does the gap between narrator and reader make the portraits do?
3. A Shakespeare tragedy
Literary analysisLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 7 (William Shakespeare)
Choose Hamlet, Othello, King Lear or Macbeth. Argue how the hero's downfall grows from a quality that also makes him admirable, using at least one soliloquy or major speech as evidence.
4. Donne's compasses
Close readingLength: 700–900 · After unit 8 (Donne, Jonson and the Early Seventeenth Century)
Read the compass conceit in "A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning" as an argument. What are the two things compared, what does each part of the instrument stand for, and what does the comparison prove to the speaker's wife? Why a drawing instrument and not a conventional image of love?
5. Milton's Satan
ArgumentLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 9 (John Milton)
Readers have long argued about whether Satan is the hero of Paradise Lost. Using his speeches in Book One ("The mind is its own place...") and his temptation of Eve in Book Nine, argue how the poem shapes our response to him.
6. The mask in A Modest Proposal
Literary analysisLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 11 (The Eighteenth Century)
Swift's "A Modest Proposal" speaks through a calm, reasonable projector. Separate the speaker from the author: what does the speaker believe, what does Swift want the reader to conclude, and which details let you tell them apart?
7. Romantic time and memory
ComparisonLength: 1,000–1,200 · After units 12 (The First Romantics); 13 (The Second Romantics and Romantic Prose)
Compare Wordsworth's "Lines Composed a Few Miles Above Tintern Abbey" with Keats's "Ode on a Grecian Urn" or Shelley's "Ozymandias". What does each poem say about what lasts (memory, art, power) and what time takes away?
8. The Duke speaks
Close readingLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 14 (Victorian Poetry)
In Browning's "My Last Duchess" the Duke of Ferrara shows an envoy his late wife's portrait. Show how the Duke reveals more than he means to, and how the dramatic monologue lets the reader judge him without the poet commenting at all.
9. Writing back to Conrad
ComparisonLength: 1,200–1,500 · After units 16 (Modernism); 18 (Commonwealth and Postcolonial Writing in English)
In a 1975 lecture, Chinua Achebe criticized Conrad's Heart of Darkness for its picture of Africa and Africans. Read Things Fall Apart (1958; in copyright: use a library copy) beside Conrad's novella. How does Achebe's portrait of Igbo society answer Conrad's? Consider narration, language and what each book lets its African characters say.
10. Orwell's officer
Literary analysisLength: 700–900 · After unit 17 (After Modernism: Britain and Ireland)
In Orwell's "Shooting an Elephant" (1936; in copyright in the U.S.: use a library anthology) an officer in Burma shoots an elephant to avoid looking foolish. How does the essay turn one incident into an argument about imperialism? Then test it against the advice on plain style in Orwell's "Politics and the English Language" (1946; also in copyright, library copy): does the earlier essay practice what the later one recommends?
Prompts: Analyzing and Interpreting Literature
Analyzing and Interpreting Literature teaches close reading of passages. These prompts turn its procedures into writing: tone, speaker, figure, form, structure, narration, style and stagecraft, ending with a timed passage analysis. Course page: Analyzing and Interpreting Literature.
1. Tone against matter
Close readingLength: 700–900 · After unit 4 (Tone, and the Tone Lexicon)
Read the opening paragraphs of Swift's "A Modest Proposal". Describe the tone with precise words from the unit's tone lexicon, then show how the gap between the calm manner and the horrifying matter makes the satire work.
2. Write a dramatic monologue
Creative with commentaryLength: 20–30 lines plus 400 words · After unit 5 (Speaker, Voice and Persona)
Write a dramatic monologue in which a speaker, addressing a silent listener at a critical moment, reveals more than he or she intends (Browning's "My Last Duchess" is the model). Then write a commentary explaining the technique: where the reader sees past the speaker, and how.
3. Two sonnet structures
ComparisonLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 9 (Poetry: Structure and Argument)
Compare Shakespeare's Sonnet 29 and Sonnet 73. Sonnet 29 turns on "yet" at line nine; Sonnet 73 offers three parallel images and draws its conclusion in the couplet. Show how each structure carries its argument, and which you find more persuasive.
4. Form in Harlem Shadows
Close readingLength: 700–900 · After unit 8 (Poetry: Closed and Open Form)
Claude McKay's "Harlem Shadows" runs to three six-line stanzas, each ending "from street to street". Show how the repetition, the stanza shape and the rhyme shape what the poem says. Why might McKay have chosen a closed form for this subject?
5. Two openings
ComparisonLength: 800–1,000 · After unit 10 (Prose: Narration and Point of View)
Compare the opening of Austen's Pride and Prejudice with the opening of Conrad's Heart of Darkness. Identify the point of view each uses, and show how each first page teaches the reader how to read the rest of the book.
6. Gradgrind built from words
Close readingLength: 700–900 · After unit 11 (Prose: Character, Scene, Style)
Read the first two chapters of Dickens's Hard Times. Show how Dickens builds Thomas Gradgrind through adjective choice, repeated sentence patterns and a family of related metaphors. Is Gradgrind flat or round on this evidence?
7. Testimony and satire
ComparisonLength: 1,000–1,200 · After unit 12 (Nonfiction: Rhetoric and the Essay)
Set a passage from Equiano's narrative (1789) beside Swift's "A Modest Proposal". Both protest cruelty, one by testimony, one by satire. Compare how each mode works on a reader, and argue which is the stronger argument for its purpose.
8. A mind under pressure
ComparisonLength: 1,000–1,200 · After units 13 (Drama: Structure and Dramatic Irony); 14 (Drama: Soliloquy, Aside, Stagecraft)
Compare Hamlet's "To be, or not to be" with Faustus's soliloquy in his last hour (Marlowe, Doctor Faustus). How does each playwright use the soliloquy to dramatize a mind under pressure: rhythm, questions, time, the turn of thought?
9. Timed passage analysis
Timed close readingLength: 40 minutes · After unit 21 (Capstone: Running the Procedure Cold)
The parent chooses an unseen passage of 15–30 lines (poem, prose or drama) from any period. In 40 minutes, with no notes, the student writes an analysis using the course's procedure: settle the speaker and situation, then tone, figures, form and structure, and end with what the passage means and how it makes that meaning. Repeat during the year with different genres.
Print one sheet for each essay.
Revision requested? Yes / No · Due: ____________ · Revised score: ______ of 16
Keep one record per student per year. It is the evidence of a writing-intensive course: what was assigned, how many drafts, and the grade. Keep the essays themselves with it.