Principles of Management / Unit 1 MGT 0016 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Performance at Three Levels
The idea
Managers answer for performance at three levels. First, individual performance has two parts: in-role performance, the duties of the job description with their productivity and quality standards, and extra-role performance, or organizational citizenship behaviors, voluntary acts such as helping a coworker that the formal reward system does not directly recognize. Second, group performance is the group's inputs minus process loss, meaning any part of group interaction that hinders its work. Third, organizational performance is increasingly judged on a triple bottom line of economic, social and environmental results. The levels must fit together: individual goals and rewards should support the group's goals.
In practice
Case problem: at Tamarack Insurance, claims processors are rewarded only for their own count of closed claims, but the department's goal is faster turnaround as a team. Lena closes the most claims but never helps with hard files; Omar closes fewer but trains every new hire. Lena excels at in-role performance, and Omar adds organizational citizenship behavior. Because the reward counts only individual output while the goal is a group goal, the two are out of line, and the firm is unlikely to build the teamwork its goal needs.
Where people slip
Do not confuse extra-role performance with weak in-role performance: citizenship behaviors add to the job's duties, not replace them. In-role and extra-role performance and process loss rest on one source.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for Principles of Management