English 9 / Unit 1 EN9 0010 worked example, 60 to 90 seconds
Asking Text-Specific Questions
The idea
A text-specific question is a question about one text that only a close reading of that text can answer. First, pick one part of the text, such as a word, a line or a choice the writer made. Second, ask how or why about that part, not yes or no. Third, check that the text itself holds the answer. Fourth, read again to answer it.
In practice
Worked example: Priya is reading a speech that repeats the word dedicate. Step one: she picks that repeated word. Step two: she asks why the speaker keeps returning to dedicate. Step three: she checks that the speech can answer this, and it can, because the word appears in several sentences. Step four: she rereads those sentences. First the speaker says the crowd came to dedicate a field. Then he says the living must dedicate themselves instead. Her question led her straight to the turn in the speech. A weaker question, such as whether she liked the speech, could not do that.
Where people slip
A good text-specific question has more than one possible answer, but every answer must come from the text. This rests on one source.
Your place on the trail
Every lesson rests on earlier ones and opens later ones. Tap any to jump.
Something wrong in this lesson? Flag it · Sources for English 9